Why Did Our Building's Insurance Premium Jump, and How Can the Board Bring It Down?

NYC coop and condo board members reviewing a building insurance renewal packet and budget at an evening board meeting

The insurance renewal quote arrived, and the number was higher than anyone expected. Maybe your building barely filed a claim this year. Maybe you had one water claim and assumed it was already priced in. Either way, you are looking at a line item large enough to squeeze the rest of the budget.

That does not mean the board did something wrong.

Insurance costs for NYC co-ops and condos always increase, but the last few years have been steeper increases than previous years. The Council of New York Cooperatives and Condominiums has reported that insurance costs rose about 120 percent between 2019 and 2024. In recent renewals, increases of 20 percent or more have been common, and the jump can be steeper when a building comes out of a preferred program.

Some of that is the market. Some of it can be specific to your building. You cannot control the first part. You can get much clearer on the second.

Here is how I put it to boards: you cannot talk the market down, but you can stop walking into renewal unprepared.

Why Did the Premium Rise If We Barely Filed a Claim?

A premium can go up even after a quiet year. Carriers price a whole class of buildings, not only your claims history. The cost of reinsurance, higher rebuild costs, and liability conditions in New York all feed into the rate you are offered. Your building can have a clean year and still see the number move.

Your building still has a story, though, and that story matters at renewal. The market sets the weather. The way the building is presented, maintained, and documented can still change how you come through it.

What About Our Building Can Move the Number?

Start with the claims history, often called a loss run. Water damage is one of the leading causes of insurance claims in multifamily buildings. A few smaller water claims can matter as much as one large one, because they can look like a pattern rather than a one-time event. That is worth knowing before the board decides, on a future small loss, whether to file a claim or handle the repair in the operating budget. It is a judgment call to make with your broker, not a reason to leave a real loss unreported.

Then look at the insured value. If it would cost more to rebuild the building today than it would have a few years ago, the replacement cost on the policy is often updated, and the premium can follow that value even if nothing else changed.

Open items can matter too. If an inspection turns up work that is still outstanding, or if recommendations from the last visit are still open, that can affect how the building is viewed. The same is true of violations still on the record. This is not about blaming anyone. It is about knowing what the underwriter is going to see, and what has already been fixed.

Finally, look at the structure of the policy itself: the deductible, the limits, and the umbrella. Sometimes part of the increase is a change in what the building is buying, or in how much coverage is still available at a price the budget can bear.

When Should the Board Start on the Renewal?

Start well before the policy expires. A practical target is about 90 days out. Quotes often arrive much closer to the expiration date, because underwriters usually do not release pricing more than 30 days ahead. That is a timing reality. It is also why waiting for the quote before the board starts its own review leaves you with very little room to work.

The earlier the board assembles the building's information, the more time the broker has to present the building clearly and, if it makes sense this year, to take the policy to market.

A few questions to put on the calendar now: When does the policy expire? When will the application, loss runs, and building updates be ready? Are we asking the broker to market the policy, and on what timeline?

What Should We Understand About the Deductible?

A higher deductible can lower the premium. It also moves more of the next loss onto the building, which can mean an assessment for owners.

Before the board changes it, get a clear picture of how much premium you actually save at each deductible level, how the proprietary lease or bylaws allocate the deductible, and whether owners' own policies, including loss assessment coverage, are likely to respond. Ask, too, whether a higher deductible should change how the building handles smaller repairs.

This is one of the easier levers to reach for, and one of the easier ones to misjudge if you only look at the premium and not at the owners.

How Can We Reduce the Risk That Keeps Showing Up on Claims?

If water is the claim that keeps appearing in buildings like yours, the most useful work happens between renewals, not the week the invoice arrives. Carriers are asking whether buildings have leak sensors, automatic shutoffs, and clear maintenance protocols for high-risk areas.

The board does not need to become the engineer. It does need to ask: Where are our highest water risks? What is already in place? What is worth documenting so the underwriter can see it? How are claims and close calls recorded? A prevention measure that exists but never makes it into the renewal submission is easy to miss.

What Should We Ask Our Broker, and What Information Should Be Current?

Ask for a plain-language explanation of the increase: how much is the market, how much is the building, and how much is a change in coverage or valuation. Ask whether the policy is being marketed, to how many markets, and what would make the building more straightforward to underwrite. Ask for options, not only a renewal number: deductible scenarios, any recommended coverage changes, and what is happening with the umbrella.

Then make sure the building information in the submission is current: unit count, capital work completed, system updates, testing records, closed claims, and recommendations that have been completed. An outdated package can make a well-run building look like a question mark.

Getting this right is more involved than a single email. Applications, loss runs, photos, inspection reports, and follow-up questions all have to line up. That is why it is hard to squeeze into the week before renewal, and why some boards want a second set of eyes on the process.

Should We Look at Insurance on Its Own?

Insurance is one of the fastest-rising costs in many building budgets, but it is still one line. A premium that looks immovable may be easier to absorb, or harder, depending on what is happening with vendors, staffing, energy, and capital work in the same year.

If the jump is large enough to force a conversation about maintenance, common charges, or an assessment, it is worth looking at the operating budget as a whole, not only at the insurance invoice. A broader cost review will not make the market softer. It can keep one line item from quietly crowding out everything else.

FAQ

What should a co-op or condo board do when the insurance premium jumps?

Start by separating what is market-wide from what is specific to the building. Then, well before the next expiration date, review the claims history, the insured value, the deductible, and the information that will go to underwriters, and ask the broker to explain the increase and, where it makes sense, to market the policy.

Can the board lower the premium by raising the deductible?

Sometimes, but not always in a way that saves the building money overall. A higher deductible can reduce the premium and still leave owners with a painful assessment after the next loss. Model the tradeoff, including how the deductible is allocated, before you change it.

When should we start the insurance renewal?

About 90 days before the policy expires. Quotes typically do not arrive until the last 30 days, so the board's preparation has to start earlier than the quote.

Does a quiet year guarantee a stable premium?

No. A clean claims year helps, but market conditions, updated replacement costs, and changes in coverage can still move the number.

If your board is also looking at how management handles renewals, claims, and the rest of the operating budget, our free guide, 100 Questions to Ask a Property Manager or Managing Agent Before You Hire Them, is a good place to begin. You'll find it, along with more guidance for boards, in our Property Management Hub.

And if you'd like a few quick tips for your board's situation, I'm always happy to chat. You can grab a time on my calendar below.

Next
Next

Interviewing Property Managers? The Questions Every NYC Co-op and Condo Board Should Ask Before You Hire